The Ultimate Makeup Remover Reviews Roundup

If you wear makeup, you need makeup remover! Gentler and more effective than soap and water, makeup remover helps you keep your skin healthy and glowing, and makeup remover reviews (like this one!) help you find the right one for your skin!

Today, options are numerous–wipes, towelettes, foaming cleansers, oils, creams, and so many more. We’re helping you sort through those cluttered makeup shelves to find what works for your skin, routine, and budget. Let’s get started!

How We Chose Our Ratings

We’re providing you with the information and data available on each product, but we also know that reviews are everything. So, we’ve looked for the most accurate and honest makeup remover reviews to bring you opinions you can trust. We left no stone unturned to find you the best.

woman taking makeup off with cotton pad

Image via Takaski

Makeup Removers Buyer’s Guide

Makeup removes fall roughly into three categories: cleansers, liquids, and pre-moistened wipes or towelettes. There are lots of variations within these categories, but let’s talk about why you might choose one over the other.


Cleansers are great for people who don’t like extra steps. If you want to use a cleanser like soap at the end of the day to remove makeup, this is for you! If you use heavy makeup, you might find this product ineffective. You also might find it too strong for sensitive places on your face, like your eyes.

Cleansers are often, however, great at double-duty. If you suffer from acne, for example, you can find a cleanser that addresses future pimples while also removing your makeup.

Wipe Away

If you don’t always want to wash your face after every makeup application, a wipe away liquid might be your best option! Designed to be used with a cotton ball or cotton round, liquid makeup remover reviews usually indicate these products are gentle yet effective.

If you want to strip away the makeup but leave your skin’s natural oils, the liquid remover is a good option. It’s also usually the most affordable of the three makeup remover options. Keep in mind, however, that it has to be used with cotton balls or other disposable products, so you’ll have to purchase these and keep them in stock.

So Easy

Hands down, the easiest way to remove makeup is with pre-moistened wipes or towelettes, such as Almay makeup remover towelettes. We’ve included an Almay Makeup Remover Wipes review below, but these are another set of options.

Both are grab and go; you can even keep them on your nightstand, so you don’t even have to use your sink to remove your makeup! The downside to these is that they’re expensive and often not effective at removing heavy makeup.

They are often infused with ingredients that help heal and purify your skin, however, which is a plus.

Ready for makeup remover reviews of specific products? We’ve got you covered; keep reading for our top three picks in each category.

Top 3 Cleanser Makeup Removers

1. Almay Makeup Remover + Cream Cleanser

5 out of 5 stars

You’ll see lots of Almay products in this roundup, and that’s for a good reason: Almay offers a great blend of effective products at affordable prices. This Makeup Remover + Cream Cleanser is no exception.

Makeup remover reviews love that it doesn’t contain microbeads, which can cause problems for the environment and can be harsh on sensitive skin. To use, you’ll apply to dry skin and then wipe off with a damp washcloth.

This Almay makeup remover cream cleanser is effective and great for dry skin thanks to heavy-duty moisturization, but if you have especially parched skin and need an extra boost, a similar option is the Almay Makeup Remover Foaming Lotion Cleanser. 

2. Clinique Take the Day Off Cleansing Balm

4.5 out of 5 stars

This balm from Clinique is a unique formula; it’s a balm rather than a lotion or liquid. It is excellent for extremely heavy makeup. In fact, makeup remover reviews report it removes makeup that other cleansers struggle with!

Unlike other cleansers, you won’t need to rinse this off, simply wipe away with a cotton round, wipe, or dry cloth.

The cons to this cleansing balm: some reviewers support their skin feels greasy after use. Also, it isn’t cheap! It’s certainly a high-end product, but you do get high-end results, which is why we gave it four stars.

3. Simple Water Boost Micellar Facial Gel Wash

4 out of 5 stars

This Micellar Gel Wash from Simple combines affordability with high-end technology in a way that we love! People with sensitive skin especially love this product as it is gentle and will not strip your skin’s natural oils. It will, however, get rid of that pesky makeup!

Simple is free of artificial colors and perfumes and uses mineral and plant extracts to hydrate and plump skin.

If you’re looking for a classic, good-for-you wash to remove your makeup, you’ve found it! The only downside is that it will not remove heavy makeup quite as effectively as the other options we’ve reviewed.

Top 3 Liquid Makeup Remover Liquids

Young beautiful woman cleaning her face with water, morning freshness, removing makeup, skin care health and beauty treatment concept, isolated on blue background

1. Clinique Take the Day Off Makeup Remover for Lids, Lashes & Lips

5 out of 5 stars

We’re starting off with a winner today. Clinique’s makeup remover reviews have long been glowing, and this is one instance where what works great for your mom or grandmother still works great!

Clinique targets the areas with the most stubborn (even waterproof) makeup: eyeshadow, eyeliner, mascara, and lipstick while managing =to keep your sensitive skin intact. It is allergy tested and safe for contact wearers. It is also paraben free.

Finally, we appreciate that, despite being a luxury product, it’s still relatively affordable. Great job, Clinique!

2. Almay Longwear & Waterproof Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

5 out of 5 stars

Another winner from Almay, this one specifically targets waterproof makeup. Something of a Clinique Take the Day Off Makeup Remover dupe, this one from Almay is much more affordable.

It promises gentle action and helps with de-puffing your eyes, plus it helps to condition your skin. If you struggle with oily skin, this may not be suitable for you (it’s not oil free), but if you have tired, dry, or dehydrated skin, you’ll love this remover from Almary!

3. Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

4.5 out of 5 stars

Oily or combination skin makeup wearers, rejoice! Neutrogena has created an eye makeup remover sans oil. If you’re frustrated by the build-up on your face and trying to counter your skin’s oil production, this is a great option for you.

Makeup remover reviews report loving that this product is phthalate free and paraben free, so it’s still safe for sensitive skin. We also love how affordable it is!

Top 3 Pre-Moistened Makeup Removers 

1. Almary Wipe It Never Happened Eye Makeup Remover Pads

5 out of 5 stars

The Almay Eye Makeup Remover Pads reviews rave about how easy and moist these pads are to use! Housed in a well-sealed plastic container, you will never have to worry about these wipes drying out. In fact, customers report they get more and more moist as you near the bottom!

These pads also get high marks for their effectiveness. Almay’s blend of green tea, aloe, and cucumber is refreshing and soothing, especially at the end of a long day.

2. Yes to Carrots & Kale Face Wipes

4 out of 5 stars

These wipes from Yes to Carrots are famous for their cheeky advertising and natural, vegan-friendly ingredients that are compostable. Made with carrot and kale vitamin boosts, these wipes leave a lovely glow.

Makeup remover reviews praise Yes to Carrots wipes for their convenience and faint, natural smell.

Our only complaint? They tend to dry out easily, forcing you to either rewet the wipe or making them not as effective.

3. Neutrogena Naturals Purifying Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes

4 out of 5 stars 

Neutrogena’s Naturals line does a great job at providing the results it promises, naturally. These wipes have been allergy and dermatologist tested, so they’re safe to use even if your skin is sensitive.

Plus, they are free from sulfates, petrolatum, dyes, phthalates, and parabens–items you’d rather not have on your skin! Our one complaint is that they are sometimes ineffective at removing eye makeup, especially mascara and eyeliner.

Which Will You Choose?

As you can see, we’ve rounded up some fantastic options for you today. All that’s left is for you to decide which new product to try. Let us know how it goes!

Speak Your Mind